SOC 2 Vendor Compare

Standards

The proposed 2027 Trust Services Criteria: a reading guide for buyers of SOC 2 software

Short answer

On 28 October 2026 the AICPA opened comment on proposed 2027 SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria and Description Criteria, with feedback due by 15 January 2027. If approved next year, the criteria would apply to engagements beginning on or after 31 December 2027, with early adoption permitted. The draft consolidates and renumbers criteria and adds points of focus on AI governance, model monitoring, prompt manipulation, data poisoning, transparency of AI-generated outputs, training data management and automated decision-making. For a buyer, it adds three questions: who remaps your controls, how the platform's own agents are governed, and whether the Description Criteria changes alter what your report must say.

By the SOC 2 Vendor Compare ledger desk · Published 2026-11-03 · Editorial assessment

What is in the draft?

Two documents: Trust Services Criteria for security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy, and the Description Criteria that govern the system description in a SOC 2 report. The AICPA describes targeted restructuring: consolidating duplicative concepts, removing criteria where appropriate, adding criteria where emphasis is needed, and revising language for a concise, uniform reading. The AI points of focus are listed as examples of the expanded considerations for emerging technology. The AICPA's vice president of assurance and advisory innovation, Amy Pawlicki, says the revisions are meant to improve usability and let the criteria adapt to rapidly evolving technologies.

What is a point of focus?

Guidance under a criterion that describes what an auditor and a service organization consider when deciding whether the criterion is met. Points of focus are not criteria and are not all required to be present. Adding AI points of focus means an auditor can reasonably ask how AI systems are governed and monitored under existing criteria, even where the criterion's wording is unchanged.

When would it apply?

Comments close 15 January 2027. If approved in 2027, the criteria would be effective for engagements beginning on or after 31 December 2027, with early adoption permitted. A Type II observation period starting in 2028 would be examined under the new criteria; one starting in 2027 would not, unless the organization adopts early.

Question one: who remaps your controls?

Every platform on the ledger holds a mapping from your controls to the criteria. A consolidation and renumbering means every platform republishes that map and every customer reviews it: orphaned controls, uncovered criteria, new points of focus to evidence. Scytale and Sprinto describe control cross-mapping on their pages; the others publish framework lists. None describes its process for a criteria revision, so ask each vendor how it handled the last one and whether the remap is included in your plan.

Question two: how are the platform's agents governed?

The agents the ledger scores under AI assistance, which draft policies, answer questionnaires, review evidence and monitor vendors, are AI systems operating on your evidence. The draft's points of focus on AI governance, transparency of outputs and automated decision-making are the questions to put to them. Scytale says its AI questionnaire answers are reviewed by a human expert and its MCP server is read-only in its first phase; Vanta describes an Agent that drafts policies and questionnaire answers. Ask every vendor what its agent can change, who reviews it and where the log is.

Question three: what changes in the description?

The Description Criteria decide what the system description in your report must cover. If they change, the description your platform helps you draft will need updating, and the report your customers read will look different from the previous year's. Ask whether the platform's description templates will be revised for the 2027 criteria and when.

Does the ledger change?

No. The ledger scores what vendors publish today. Each vendor profile now carries a short note under audit path pointing to this guide, and the demo question list adds the three questions above.

What else do buyers ask?

When do the proposed 2027 SOC 2 criteria take effect?

If approved, for engagements beginning on or after 31 December 2027, with early adoption permitted. Comments on the exposure draft are open until 15 January 2027.

What AI topics does the draft add?

Points of focus on AI governance, model monitoring, prompt manipulation, data poisoning, transparency of AI-generated outputs, training data management and the risks of automated decision-making.

What are the sources?

Source: AICPA news release, 28 October 2026 · read 2026-11-05

Source: AICPA exposure drafts, proposed 2027 SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria and Description Criteria · read 2026-11-05

Source: Journal of Accountancy, October 2026 · read 2026-11-05

Related

More posts